
Thomas Mott Osborne Brings Reform to Sing Sing Prison
Clip: Episode 2 | 10m 39sVideo has Closed Captions
After experiencing being imprisoned, Thomas Mott Osborne dedicates himself to reforming Sing Sing.
Successful businessman Thomas Mott Osborne becomes interested with the concept of reforming America's prisons. In 1913, Osborne voluntarily spends 7 days in Auburn Prison, an experience that profoundly changes him. When he is placed in charge of Sing Sing Prison, he makes strides to improve the conditions of the incarcerated, although his efforts are undermined by the political establishment.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

Thomas Mott Osborne Brings Reform to Sing Sing Prison
Clip: Episode 2 | 10m 39sVideo has Closed Captions
Successful businessman Thomas Mott Osborne becomes interested with the concept of reforming America's prisons. In 1913, Osborne voluntarily spends 7 days in Auburn Prison, an experience that profoundly changes him. When he is placed in charge of Sing Sing Prison, he makes strides to improve the conditions of the incarcerated, although his efforts are undermined by the political establishment.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Measuring Crime and Punishment
How does the way we collect and measure crime shape our understanding of it? Crime statistics can tell us how crime changes over time. But the way crime is measured, defined, and communicated can also shape public perception and policy.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipNarrator: In the early 1900s, many of America's prisons were nearly 100 years old.
The conditions inside them were more deplorable than ever.
Under pressure from labor groups who resented the unfair competition, New York and many other states had banned private contractors.
But without their fees, there was not enough funding for staff or basic supplies.
When prisoners at Sing Sing were given only rancid food, they refused to eat it and rioted in protest.
[People shouting] The growing prison crisis deeply concerned Thomas Mott Osborne.
Like many Progressive reformers, he was determined to do something about the problems that plagued American society.
Rebecca McLennan: Thomas Mott Osborne grew up in Upstate New York, the son of a very successful businessman.
He was a very colorful character.
He actually had quite a bit of experience with theatre, enjoyed the theatre.
He was a Progressive-era eccentric, basically a millionaire, who became very interested in the cause of prison reform, as were many middle- and upper middle-class Americans in those days.
Voice: It was known already that the conditions at Sing Sing were barbaric, and those at Auburn medieval.
I was interested in the actual effect of the system as a whole on the prisoners.
I resolved to inform myself as to the inner conditions of the prisons and the needs of the inmates.
Thomas Mott Osborne.
Narrator: In September of 1913, Osborne went to Auburn Prison.
He told the 1,400 men there that he had been given permission to do something no other prison reformer had ever done: spend seven days living behind bars with them.
Voice: Most of the books that have been written about you by "experts" are based upon the false and cruel assumption that the prisoner is not a human being like the rest of us but a strange sort of animal called a "criminal."
I am coming here to learn what I can at first hand.
To live your life; to be housed, clothed, fed, treated in all respects like one of you.
I want to see for myself exactly what your life is like, not from the outside looking in but from the inside looking out.
[Thomas Mott Osborne] Narrator: Osborne was fingerprinted, photographed, and measured according to the Bertillon system.
He was given a uniform and an ID number, and for the next week, he went by the name of "Tom Brown."
Voice: Cell 15, second tier, north wing, Auburn Prison.
I am a prisoner, locked, double locked, conscious of a horrible feeling of constraint, of confinement.
How in the world do they bear it, the men who look forward to long years of imprisonment?
What a commentary on our civilization that we can do nothing better with such men than to throw away their lives and ruin them, body and soul.
God!
What a miserable, shameful waste of human life, of human energy!
[Thomas Mott Osborne] Narrator: Before he left Auburn, Osborne wanted to experience solitary confinement in the prison's punishment cells, where the men were kept in total darkness, allowed just one cup of water and a piece of bread each day.
Voice: I enter my iron cage.
It is absolutely empty of everything except a bucket.
There is no seat, no bed, no place to wash, no water to wash with.
[Thomas Mott Osborne] Narrator: There were five other men in the solitary cells near Osborne.
He could not see any of them, but through the door of his cell, he talked to them for hours.
It was, he remembered, one of the "most intelligent, instructive, and entertaining conversations" he had ever had.
One of the men, who was ill, became distraught when he spilled the only cup of water he would be given that day.
One of the other prisoners spent hours comforting him.
Voice: Never have I witnessed a finer act of Christian charity toward suffering humanity, never more skillful treatment of a sick and nervous fellow-creature.
These prisoners are men-- real men-- your brethren and mine.
If you treat them like beasts, it will be hard for them to keep from degenerating into beasts.
If you treat them like men, you can help them to rise.
The real miracle is when men who have been treated for many years like beasts persist in retaining their humanity.
[Thomas Mott Osborne] Narrator: Though Osborne was not the first reformer to expose terrible conditions in America's prisons, he was by far the most well-connected.
He published "Within Prison Walls" about the week he spent inside Auburn, and in 1914, he was appointed the warden of Sing Sing.
He allowed the prisoners there more autonomy and individual freedom than any American prison had, because, he said, "It is liberty alone that fits men for liberty."
The men established a "Mutual Welfare League," that held elections, set rules of conduct, handled disciplinary matters, and when World War I broke out in Europe, they knitted clothes for the Polish Relief Committee.
"It's a real comfort," one man said, "to be doing something for those who are more unfortunate than ourselves."
Osborne recruited some of America's leading industrialists to provide classes in automobile maintenance, accounting, architectural drawing, and foreign languages, and to offer the men who took the classes employment upon release.
Some began to refer to the prison as the "University of Sing Sing."
McLennan: Now, there was one caveat to this, which is that Osborne, and most of the other Progressive reformers, brought racial prejudice into that equation.
And a kind of racial hierarchy begins to play out in ways that were not so much the case in the contracting system, ironically enough, because all contractors cared about was, "Are you fast at making barrels?"
Narrator: Osborne excluded the prison's small Black population from the training programs.
They were assigned to "unskilled" work details.
He also arranged for many of them to be transferred to Clinton, the least reformed and most violent prison in the state.
McLennan: Osborne had a publicist, and so Sing Sing, in about a 12-month period, became a really fascinating national, if not international, showcase for incarceration in the United States.
Narrator: Progressives like the up-and-coming Democrat Franklin Delano Roosevelt admired Osborne's reforms, but his approach to running Sing Sing won him powerful enemies as well.
The Republican governor who had appointed him resented Osborne's independence, and he never had the support of Tammany Hall Democrats.
McLennan: Tammany Hall was largely responsible for supplying guards for the institution.
And certainly, he didn't bring them in on the decision-making process.
He didn't consult with the very people who'd been guarding the Sing Sing population for generations.
And so between Tammany and the Republicans, Osborne did not consider himself accountable or answerable to anybody.
Narrator: When Osborne discovered that one of the prisoners at Sing Sing had had sex with 21 other men, possibly in exchange for food or other favors, he disciplined them all in the manner he thought best: putting them to work digging a sewer.
But he chose not to report any of it to the state, as was required by law.
When the state superintendent of prisons found out what Osborne had failed to do, he launched a grand jury investigation.
22 prisoners were indicted, and so was Thomas Mott Osborne.
McLennan: Osborne is ultimately the target of a kind of frame-up.
So, his political enemies mobilized against him, and they were effective.
Narrator: Osborne was accused of perjury, neglect of duty, and, most damaging, having committed what the prosecutor called "various unnatural and immoral acts with the convicts of Sing Sing."
He was eventually cleared of all charges, but the damage to his reputation was done.
McLennan: It ends his career at Sing Sing, closed down his career as a prison reformer, and arguably, it ends his life.
He dies a few years later a very heartbroken man.
Narrator: There would always be classes and programs in some prisons, but few wardens would fully embrace Osborne's philosophy of self-governance and rehabilitation.
Betts: You see a situation like a Sing-Sing, and you realize that Osborne invented this thing or created this thing and did create it with real intentions that were probably profound.
And the real question becomes, was there enough time to see if it was sustainable?
And the answer has been no.
There are always charismatic prison officials, charismatic wardens, but it is a bureaucracy.
And I think a lot of people just kind of are pushing to keep their jobs.
It's a tragic story because nobody gets rewarded for making the lives of people in prison better.
Clara Sheldon Smith's stunning mug shots
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 1m 53s | Photographer Clara Sheldon Smith captures hundreds of mugshots in the early 20th century. (1m 53s)
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 5m 37s | The American public grapples with the question of if criminals are born or made. (5m 37s)
The Execution of Roxalana Druse
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 2m 34s | In 1887, the botched hanging of Roxalana Druse causes Americans to rethink the death penalty. (2m 34s)
The Federal Government vs. Indigneous Justice
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 4m 45s | After a Lakota leader is murdered, the federal government overrules the tribe's resolution. (4m 45s)
The Green Goods Game: The Most Devious Scam in America
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 7m 42s | Unable to find legal work, George Appo turns to a devious scam, the green goods game, to make money. (7m 42s)
How Racism and Eugenics Impacted the Criminal Justice System
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 3m 22s | As millions of immigrants flood to the United States, the popularity of the eugenics movement grows. (3m 22s)
Inspector Thomas Byrnes and the Evolution of Policing
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 11m 38s | Inspector Thomas Byrnes reinvents policing tactics in the 19th century using brutal methods. (11m 38s)
Lawyer Clarence Darrow Steps Up to Defend the Sweet Family
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 11m 10s | The legendary lawyer Clarence Darrow defends the Sweet family in their murder trial case. (11m 10s)
The Lexow Commission Exposes Police Brutality and Corruption
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 8m 40s | In 1894, the Lexow Commission forms to investigate corruption and police brutality among the NYPD. (8m 40s)
The Police Clash with Bootleggers Over Prohibition
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 5m 27s | Prohibition creates a black market for alcohol, leaving police struggling with enforcement. (5m 27s)
The Story of the Sweet Family and Housing Segregation
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 8m 53s | A white mob gathers to force the Sweet family into fleeing their new house in Detroit. (8m 53s)
Suffragists Tell the Stories of Incarcerated Women
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep2 | 6m 26s | Suffragist Kate Richards O'Hare details the experiences of the women she meets while incarcerated. (6m 26s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...




























